FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstract, dissertation, book

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 25 |

«Item type text; Electronic Dissertation Authors Dean, Erin Publisher The University of Arizona. Rights Copyright © is held by the author. Digital ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Beyond Community: "Global" Conservation Networks and

"Local" Organization in Tanzania and Zanzibar

Item type text; Electronic Dissertation

Authors Dean, Erin

Publisher The University of Arizona.

Rights Copyright © is held by the author. Digital access to this

material is made possible by the University Libraries,

University of Arizona. Further transmission, reproduction

or presentation (such as public display or performance) of

protected items is prohibited except with permission of the author.

Downloaded 7-May-2016 18:45:54 Link to item http://hdl.handle.net/10150/195624




by Erin Dean _____________________

A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the


In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of


In the Graduate College




As members of the Dissertation Committee, we certify that we have read the dissertation prepared by ERIN DEAN entitled BEYOND COMMUNITY: "GLOBAL" CONSERVATION NETWORKS AND


and recommend that it be accepted as fulfilling the dissertation requirement for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Date: August 14, 2007 _______________________________________________________________________

Diane Austin Date: August 14, 2007 _______________________________________________________________________

Mamadou Baro Date: August 14, 2007 _______________________________________________________________________

Steve Lansing Date: August 14, 2007 _______________________________________________________________________

William Shaw Date: August 14, 2007 _______________________________________________________________________

Garth Myers Final approval and acceptance of this dissertation is contingent upon the candidate’s submission of the final copies of the dissertation to the Graduate College.

I hereby certify that I have read this dissertation prepared under my direction and recommend that it be accepted as fulfilling the dissertation requirement.

________________________________________________ Date: August 14, 2007 Dissertation Director: Diane Austin

–  –  –

This dissertation has been submitted in partial fulfillment of requirements for an advanced degree at the University of Arizona and is deposited in the University Library to be made available to borrowers under rules of the Library.

Brief quotations from this dissertation are allowable without special permission, provided that accurate acknowledgment of source is made. Requests for permission for extended quotation from or reproduction of this manuscript in whole or in part may be granted by the head of the major department or the Dean of the Graduate College when in his or her judgment the proposed use of the material is in the interest of scholarship. In all other instances, however, permission must be obtained from the author.

–  –  –

It is the nature of Anthropology that we are always deeply indebted to the people who have so graciously chosen to share their lives with us, and the long process of obtaining a graduate degree compounds those debts. It is a massive understatement to say that this work would not have been possible without the assistance of many people. Though recognizing this statement’s inadequacy, I would like to make a brief attempt to express my heartfelt appreciation for their continuing support and encouragement.

First, I am humbled and honored by the kindness and hospitality of the people of Jongowe and Ngaramtoni. I am especially grateful to Makame Muhajir, Iddie Haji, Tatu Selima, and Salim Makame Ali in Jongowe for their practical assistance, but principally for their friendship and unflagging good humor. In Ngaramtoni, Elias and Rose Ngungat opened their home to me and included me in their family. Thank you. I am also indebted to Fadhil Walele and his family, who helped me in countless ways and made every trip to Dar es Salaam interesting and fun. Mussa Sheha and his wife Sauma, provided similar, much appreciated support in Stonetown. The staff at COSTECH, the Zanzibar Archives as well as the faculty, staff, and students at the Forestry Training Institute in Ol Motonyi provided both practical and moral support for this research, and I am grateful. Thank you to Kristin Phillips, Liz Singleton, Karen Milch, Tim Park, and Howard Frederick for their friendship and willingness to provide needed distractions, and to Andrew Williams, a generous scholar who is making a difference.

I would especially like to thank all the members of Osotwa and JEMA, particularly the organizations’ leaders. This research is entirely based on your willingness to open your organizations to scrutiny, and I am moved by your courage. Your concern for your neighbors, your on-going struggles to improve your communities, your thoughtful and occasionally brutal honesty, and your endurance in the face of so many challenges is inspirational to me and to all who have the privilege of working with you.

I have been very lucky to work with the talented scholars on my dissertation committee—they have been tireless and tolerant. Thank you to Diane Austin, Mamadou Baro, Steve Lansing, Bill Shaw, and Garth Myers for their support and encouragement for all these years. Besides being a dissertation director, Diane Austin has been a mentor, advisor, and friend for eight years, and it is impossible to adequately thank her for all she has done for me. Her ethical and intellectual rigor has set a model I strive to emulate. In addition to serving as an outside member of my committee, Garth Myers was pivotal in developing and supporting this research project, and has always been a source of encouragement and insight.

This research was funded through a Fulbright-Hayes Doctoral Dissertation Research Abroad fellowship, and I am grateful for the support. Thank you to Makame Muhajir and Andrew Gardner for their insightful comments on early chapters and drafts and Tom McGuire for a useful discussion on fisheries. Thank you to Sarah Dahlen for her friendship and spare bedroom. Thank you to my parents, who never told me a PhD in Anthropology was crazy, even if they thought so. And finally, thank you to my husband, Steinur Bell, who inspires me further every day.







The National Park Model

Emergence of a new model: Community-based natural resource management

CBNRM in Action

Critiques of CBNRM

New Directions


Site selection

Data collection

Structure of Dissertation


Island Conservation: Jongowe and JEMA

From city-state to village

Deceptive isolation

Cooperative organization in Jongowe

Forest Conservation: Mount Meru and Osotwa

A Settled Pastoralist Identity

Cooperative Organization in Ngaramtoni




Knowledge of the Sea:

Traditional “Ecological” Knowledge?

Knowledge of the Land

“Traditional” Ecological Knowledge?

Traditional Ecological “Knowledge”?




The Emergence of NGOs

Governing the Environment



Non-governing the Environment

The Politics of Partnership

CBC and the Meru-Usa Forest Plantation

The Meru-Usa Forest Plantation


The role of a CBO

Negotiating the state and civil society



Strategy One: Identity definition and manipulation:

Strategy Two: Know what is being funded

Strategy Three: Be fluent in the language of development

Strategy Four: Utilize the “elite”

The Consequences of Conservation Networks

Mixed Messages: The results of networking for CBOs

Uneven Distribution: Consequences of conservation networks for communities

Opportunistic Management: Consequences for donors

Escalation of Authority: Consequences for government

Consequences for the environment



Resilience of local authority

An empty bag cannot stand upright

WORKS CITED…………………………………………………………………...…...211


Figure 1: Jongowe village in 2005

Figure 2: Small fishing dhow

Figure 3: Reading the day's news in Stonetown

Figure 4: Waarusha farmer

Figure 5: Boys herding in Ngaramtoni

Figure 6: Zero-grazing enclosure in Ngaramtoni

Figure 7: Boat on beach for repairs

Figure 8: Fishermen repairing nets

Figure 9: Sealing cracks in dhow with cotton

Figure 10: Burning the final coat of sealant, made of shark bile

Figure 11: Girls with clams they gathered

Figure 12: Hunting octopus

Figure 13: Woman with choroko crop

Figure 14: Woman burning her fields

Figure 15: Farm bordering the forest plantation

Figure 16: Walking through the Meru-Usa plantation

Figure 17: Grandmother and her grandchildren, all of whom were orphaned by AIDS.172


This dissertation explores the complex structures and diverse experiences of globalization through the specific analytical lens of community-based natural resource management (CBNRM). CBNRM is an undertaking which is fundamentally local but also integrally connected to transnational conservation ideology and national structures of authority.

While recent critiques of community-based conservation projects have challenged the universal efficacy of the approach, CBNRM continues to be a ubiquitous conservation paradigm and to provide lingering hope for local empowerment through resource management. Focusing on two community-based conservation groups formed in Tanzania and Zanzibar, this dissertation looks at the experience of local groups attempting to engage with broader national or international conservation networks by focusing on three tropes of globalization theory: intersections between traditional ecological knowledge and western science, the relationship between civil society and the state, and the specific mechanisms for local engagement with national and global entities.

The community groups in this study use dynamic and adaptive strategies to channel resources into their communities. However, they also face significant structural constraints, many of which reveal the neocolonial effects of transnational conservation ideology. This work explores both the factors limiting or manipulating local participation in resource management and the strategies used by these two community-based conservation groups to ensure their participation in spite of those limitations.

–  –  –

I first began researching community-based conservation in 1997, when I studied in Kenya with St. Lawrence University’s Kenya Semester Program. The final component of the semester was an independent internship project, and mine was with Kenya Wildlife Service and their fledgling Partnerships Program in Tsavo National Park. The purpose of the program was to address the continuing conflicts between local residents and wildlife (and consequently local residents and park personnel) through community-based conservation programs. After a month of interviews with park officials, scientists, game wardens, and, most importantly, residents living near park borders, I realized the complexity of the task Kenya Wildlife Service had set for itself in reconciling decades of acrimonious relationships and meeting the needs of the diverse people whose homes bordered the park. Lingering anger over the original expulsions after park gazettement, as well as resentment regarding poaching, unauthorized grazing, and deaths caused by wildlife poisoned local relationships. Also, national concerns of corruption, ethnic tensions, and the freezing of donor funding to the country as a whole challenged the attempts at creating viable “community-based” programs. It was clear that the “partnerships” desired by the government—that is, revenue sharing in exchange for local cooperation—did not mesh with the level of control and access to resources desired by residents. I was quickly disillusioned by the reality of “community-based conservation.” In spite of the difficulties, I was also convinced of the ultimate, simple truth that the only way to successfully protect the unique wildlife and resources of the area was through securing the cooperation and support of local people. For it to succeed, environmental conservation had to also address issues of social justice and economic development. While fraught with challenges and difficulties, community-based conservation also offered the best hope for improving the lives of people in East Africa through, rather than in opposition to, resource management.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 25 |

Similar works:

«AN INTRODUCTION TO QUICKBOOKS ONLINE Getting Started Guide Copyright Copyright 2015 Intuit Ltd. All rights reserved. Intuit Australia Intuit Australia is a company registered in Australia ABN 28 163 072 704. Trademarks ©2015 Intuit Inc. All rights reserved. Intuit the Intuit logo, Lacerte, ProAdvisor, ProSeries and QuickBooks, among others, are trademarks or registered trademarks of Intuit Inc. in the United States and other countries. Other parties’ marks are the property of their...»

«BACHELORARBEIT Umweltbewusstsein in der Werbefilmbranche Wunsch und Wirklichkeit Karen Schmidt Hamburg, 2012 Fakultät: Medien BACHELORARBEIT Umweltbewusstsein in Werbefilmbranche Wunsch und Wirklichkeit Autorin: Karen Schmidt Studiengang: Angewandte Medienwirtschaft Seminargruppe: AM09sT1-B Erstprüfer: Prof. Dr. Detlef Gwosc Zweitprüfer: Dipl. Ing. Johannes Dornow Einreichung: Hamburg, 2012 Faculty of Media BACHELOR THESIS Ecological Awareness in the Advertising Film Industry Desire and...»

«Környezetkímélő talajművelési rendszerek Magyarországon – elmélet és gyakorlat – Szerkesztette: Madarász Balázs Környezetkímélő talajművelési rendszerek Magyarországon – elmélet és gyakorlat – Szerkesztette MADARÁSZ BALÁZS MTA CSFK Földrajztudományi Intézet Budapest, 2015 Szerkesztette MADARÁSZ BALÁZS A tanulmányokat lektorálták BÁDONYI KRISZTINA BÍRÓ BORBÁLA JAKAB GERGELY MADARÁSZ BALÁZS SZALAI ZOLTÁN TÓTH ADRIENN ZACHÁRY DÓRA A kötet kiadását...»

«TEXTE 22/2010 Transboundary shipment of waste electrical and electronic equipment / electronic scrap Optimization of material flows and control | TEXTE | 22/2010 ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH OF THE FEDERAL MINISTRY OF THE ENVIRONMENT, NATURE CONSERVATION AND NUCLEAR SAFETY Project No. (FKZ) 3708 93 300 Report No. (UBA-FB) 001331/E Transboundary shipment of waste electrical and electronic equipment / electronic scrap – Optimization of material flows and control by Knut Sander Stephanie Schilling...»

«И. В. Мерсиянова И. И. Солодова Фонды местных сообществ как технология решения социальных проблем на местном уровне Электронный ресурс URL: http://www.civisbook.ru/files/File/Mersiyanova160-179.pdf Перепечатка с сайта НИУ-ВШЭ http://www.hse.ru МОНИТОРИНГ Мерсиянова И.В., Солодова И.И. ФОНДЫ МЕСТНЫХ СООБЩЕСТВ...»

«Diss. ETH No. 17477 Numerical Analysis of Mixture Formation and Combustion in a Hydrogen Direct-Injection Internal Combustion Engine A dissertation submitted to the SWISS FEDERAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ZURICH for the degree of DOCTOR OF SCIENCE presented by UDO GERKE Dipl.-Ing. Uni. Stuttgart born February 26th, 1978 citizen of Munich, Germany accepted on the recommendation of Prof. Dr. Konstantinos Boulouchos, ETH Zurich, examiner Prof. Dr. Andreas Wimmer, TU Graz, co-examiner Prof. Dr. Aldo...»

«UNIVERSIDAD INTERNACIONAL DE ANDALUCÍA Sede Antonio Machado, Baeza (Jaén) Spain 2009-2011 BIENNIUM 9th MASTER’S DEGREE IN MANAGEMENT, ACCESS AND CONSERVATION OF SPECIES IN TRADE: THE INTERNATIONAL FRAMEWORK WITH THE COLLABORATION OF: SECRETARÍA GENERAL DE COMERCIO EXTERIOR AND THE PARTICIPATION OF: th th On-campus period: from 5 April to 25 June, 2010 The Master’s Degree Course has already been given eight times by the International University of Andalusia. In its last four editions, the...»

«Do not remove this if sending to pagerunnerr Page Title Guidance to UK Flagged Shipping on Measures to Counter Piracy, Armed Robbery and Other Acts of Violence Against Merchant Shipping November 2011 The information or guidance in this document (including third party information, products and services), is provided by DfT on an 'as is' basis, without any representation or endorsement made and without warranty of any kind whether express or implied. The Department for Transport has actively...»

«VENDÉGELŐADÁSOK ULRICH H. J. KÖRTNER Diakónia a minőség, keresztyén önértelmezés és gazdaságosság feszültségében Teológiai-etikai reflexiók1 ZUSAMMENFASSUNG Am Qualitätsbegriff und an der Diskussion über Qualitätssicherung und Qualitätsmanagement lassen sich gleichermaßen der innere Zusammenhang wie auch die Spannungen und Widersprüche zwischen christlichem Profil und Ökonomisierung diakonischen Handelns ablesen. Kritischer Maßstab für den Qualitätsbegriff in der...»

«. No.AV.13030/34/2013-DT Government of India Ministry of Civil Aviation •• *44*** **** ?lc** B Block, Rajiv Gandhi Bhawan New Delhi, dated 24.9.2013 To, 1. Federation offlidian Airlines'. • 1-1734, First Floor, Chittaranjan Park, New.Delhi 110019. 2., IATA Agents Association of India CentrarSocretariat, C/o Speedwings Travel•& Cargo (p) Ltd., Sreekandath Road, Cochin 682016.3. Travel Agents Federation of India, National Secretariat, 509 The Avenue International Airport Road Opp....»

«Komponenten, Komponentenframeworks und Gluing 1 Oscar Nierstrasz, Markus Lumpe Software Composition Group, University of Berne2 Abstract. In der letzten Zeit wird immer häufiger von komponentenorientierter Softwareentwicklung gesprochen, wobei meistens nicht klar ist, was darunter eigentlich zu verstehen ist. Was macht ein Stück Software zur Komponente? Wir sagen, daß Softwarekomponenten in einer speziellen Art und Weise konstruiert werden müssen, um mit anderen Komponenten zu einer...»

«293 Dezentrierung und Verkippung der neuen TecnisZCB00-Intraokularlinse im Vergleich mit der Linsenposition im jugendlichen Auge U. Mester, T. Sauer, H. Kaymak Zusammenfassung Hintergrund: Bekanntermaßen beeinträchtigen Verkippung und Dezentrierung von Intraokularlinsen (IOL) die Abbildungsqualität des Auges. Dies gilt im Besonderen für asphärische IOLs. In einer prospektiven Untersuchung wurden daher Verkippung und Dezentrierung der einstückigen asphärischen Tecnis IOL (ZCB00) gemessen...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.abstract.xlibx.info - Free e-library - Abstract, dissertation, book

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.