WWW.ABSTRACT.XLIBX.INFO FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstract, dissertation, book

<< HOME
CONTACTS

Pages:   || 2 |

# «AN ANALOGUE OF PTOLEMY’S THEOREM AND ITS CONVERSE IN HYPERBOLIC GEOMETRY JOSEPH EARL VALENTINE Vol. 34, No. 3 July 1970 PACIFIC JOURNAL OF ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Pacific Journal of

Mathematics

## JOSEPH EARL VALENTINE

Vol. 34, No. 3 July 1970

## PACIFIC JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICS

Vol. 34, No. 3, 1970

## JOSEPH E. VALENTINE

The purpose of this paper is to give a complete answer to the question: what relations between the mutual distances of n (n ^ 3) points in the hyperbolic plane are necessary and sufficient to insure that those points lie on a line, circle, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve, respectively ?

In 1912 Kubota [6] proved an analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem in the hyperbolic plane and recently Kurnick and Volenic [7] obtained another analogue. In 1947 Haantjes [4] gave a proof of the hyperbolic analogue of the ptolemaic inequality, and in [5] he developed techniques which give a new proof of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse in the euclidean plane. In the latter paper it is further stated that these techniques give proofs of an analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse in the hyperbolic plane. However, Haantjes' analogue of the converse of Ptolemy's Theorem is false, since Kubota [6] has shown that the determinant | smh\PiPs/2) |, where i, j = 1, 2, 3, 4, vanishes for four points P19 P2, P3, P 4 on a horocycle in the hyperbolic plane. So far as the author knows, Haantjes is the only person who has mentioned an analogue of the converse of Ptolemy's Theorem in the hyperbolic plane.

Relations between the mutual distances of three points are obtained which are necessary and sufficient to insure that those points determine a line, circle, horocycle, or equidistant curve, respectively.

It will be recalled that Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse for the euclidean plane may be stated as follows.

(Ptolemy). Four points P19 P2, P3, P 4 of the euclidean

## THEOREM

plane lie on a circle or line if and only if the determinant C(Plf P2, P3, P4) = I PiPj21 vanishes, where PiPά = P^ denotes the distance of the points Piy P3, (i, j = 1, 2, 3, 4).

The analogous theorem which will be proved in this paper is the following.

THEOREM. Four points Plf P2, P3, P 4 of the hyperbolic plane lie on a circle, line, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve if and only if the determinant 818 JOSEPH E. VALENTINE I sinh (PiPj/2) \ vanishes (i, j = 1, 2, 3, 4).

Moreover, the techniques used in this paper provide an easy extension of this analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse to give necessary and sufficient conditions for n, (n ^ 4), points to lie on a line, circle, horocycle, or equidistant curve.

2* Preliminary remarks* It is well known [1, pp. 273-274] that the determinants A4(P,, P2, P3, P4) - ( cosh (PtPj) I, (i, j = 1, 2, 3, 4) and A5(Ply P2, P3, P4, P5) = I cosh (PtPj) I, (i, j = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5) vanish for each quadruple and each quintuple of points in the hyperbolic plane. Moreover, A,(Pίy P2, P3) = | cosh (P^) | ^ 0, (i, i = 1,2, 3) for each triple of points and vanishes if and only if the triple is collinear. These determinants play an important part in this paper.

Poincare's circular model of the hyperbolic plane will be used.

3* Analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse* As was indicated in the § 2, we will use Poincare's model of the hyperbolic plane. In order to prove the analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse, the "cross ratio" of four points is defined and shown to be an inversive invariant. Since lines, circles, horocycles, and equidistant curves are all equivalent under the group generated by hyperbolic inversions, this reduces Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse to that of considering four points on a line.

DEFINITION 3.1. If A, B, C, D are four distinct points, then the

cross ratio {AB, CD) is defined by:

{AB, CD) = [sinh AC/2 sinh BD/2] / [sinh AD/2 sinh BC/2].

–  –  –

Substituting the values of (*, *), together with the same identities when x9 X are replaced by y, Y, respectively, in (*) and solving the

new equation for sinh X ' Y'/2, we obtain:

sinh X ' Γ'/2 - k[(l-x2)/(x2 - k2)]1'2 [(l-y2)/(y2 - k2)]112 sinh 1 7 / 2. (r) Application of (τ) to all pairs of any four points A, J5, C, D yields,

–  –  –

Proo/. Since Λ4(P1? P 2, P 3, P4) = 0, it follows that the determinant H obtained from Λ4(P1? P2, Pz, P 4 ), by bordering it with a first row and a first column with a common element — 1, and the rest of the elements in the first column all ones and the rest of the elements in the first row all zeroes, also vanishes.

The result of subtracting the first column of this bordered determinant from the second, third, fourth, and fifth columns, respectively, and making use of the fact that cosh(β) — 1 = 2 sinh2(#/2) is

–  –  –

If the four points contain a nonlinear triple, assume the labeling so that Λ3(P2, P 3, P4) Φ 0. Letting [1, 2] denote the cofactor of the element in the first row and second column, an expansion theorem from determinants yields

–  –  –

quently, the rank of the determinant in (1) is three. Therefore, K(P1,P2,Ps,Pi) = 0.

If P, Q, R, S is a quadruple of distinct points, then COROLLARY.

the three products, sinh (PQ/2) sinh(i2S/2), sinh (PR/2) sinh (QS/2), sinh (PS/2) sinh (QR/2), of the hyperbolic sines of half the "opposite" distances satisfy the triangle inequality.

–  –  –

REMARK. The above corollary is the hyperbolic analogue of the ptolemaic inequality. It has been shown [3] that the ptolemaic inequality itself is valid in the hyperbolic plane.

–  –  –

THEOREM 3.3.

// P, Q, R, S are distinct points and if PR//QS then {PS, QR} + {PQ, RS} = 1.

Proof. Theorem 3.2 and the above remarks show the validity of the theorem in case the cycle is a line. Suppose, then, that the four points lie on a horocycle, circle or equidistant curve. There exists an inversion which maps such a cycle onto a line. Thus, if P', Sr, Qr,Rf ANALOGUE OF PTOLEMY'S THEOREM 821 are the inverse points of P, Q, R, S then P'R'HQ'S' and {P'S'9 Q'R'} + {P'Q', R'S'} = 1. Since cross ratio is an inversive invariant, {PS, QR} + {PQ, RS} = 1.

THEOREM 3.4.

// P, Q, iϋ, £ are four distinct points such that {PS, QR} + {PQ, RS} = 1 then PR//QS.

Proof. Three points of the hyperbolic plane lie on a line, circle, horocycle, or equidistant curve. We first suppose three of the points, say, Q, R, S are collinear. Since Q, R, S are collinear, Λ3 (Q, R, S) — 0, K(Q, R,S)^0 and with the notation of Theorem 3.2, I(Q, R, S) = 0.

By hypothesis K (P, Q, R, S) = 0, and I(P, Q, R, S) = 0. It now follows that the rank of I (P, Q, R, S) is three. Consequently, the rank of Λ4 (P, Q, R, S) is two. Therefore, Λ3 (P, Q, S) = 0 and P, Q, S are collinear. It now follows that P, Q, i?, S are collinear and PR//QS.

If Q, R, S lie on any cycle, this cycle may be mapped onto a line by an inversion. If P',ζ', R', S' are inverse points of P, Q, i2, S then by the above, P'R'UQ'S'. If the line of P', Q', i2', S' is mapped back onto the cycle of Q, R, S by the same inversion, it follows that PR//QS.

The following theorem, which is a hyperbolic analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse, has now been obtained.

THEOREM 3.5.

Four distinct points P19 P 2, P3, P 4 of the hyperbolic plane lie on a line, circle, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve if and only if the determinant K{Pt, P2, P3, P4) = I sinWiPiPj/Z) | vanishes (i, j - 1, 2, 3, 4).

In order to obtain the generalization of this analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse, we need the following lemma.

LEMMA 3.6.

If P19 P 2, P3, P 4, P 5 are five points then the determinant K{Pt, P2, P3, P4, P5) = I smh^PiPj'β) \ vanishes (i, j^ = 1,2,3,4,5).

Proof. Since the rank of A5(PX, P2, P3, P4, P5) is less than or equal to three, it follows that the determinant, H, obtained from Λ5 (P19 P2, P3, P4, P5) by bordering it with a first column and a first row with common element —1, and the rest of the elements of the first column all ones and the rest of the element in the first row all zeroes has rank less than or equal to four. The determinant, I, obtained from H by substracting the first column from the second, third, 822 JOSEPH E. VALENTINE fourth, fifth and sixth columns, respectively, and then substituting 2 sinh2(#/2) for cosh (x) — 1 also has rank less than or equal to four.

Hence K(Pl9 P2, P3, P4, P5) = 0.

3.7. If P19 P 2, «, P W are w pairwίse distinct points

## THEOREM

of the hyperbolic plane, (n ^ 4), ί/^ew necessary and sufficient condition that P19 P 2,, P Λ ϊie ow a iwβ, circle, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve is that the matrix

–  –  –

Proof. Suppose P 1? P2,, P w are pair wise distinct points of the hyperbolic plane which lie on a line, circle, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve. Then the leading principal minor of order three of K (P19 P2,, Pn) is nonzero, while the determinants obtained from this principal minor by adjoining one row and one column or two rows and two columns vanish by Theorem 3.3 and Lemma 3.6, respectively. It follows that the rank of K(P19P2, •, Pn) is three.

Conversely, if the rank of K(P19, Pn) is three then every principal minor of K (P19 P2, «,P Λ ) of order four is zero. It follows from Theorem 3.5 that each quadruple of the points and hence the n points lie on a line, circle, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve.

4* Circles, horocycles and equidistant curves* It is noted, in the hyperbolic analogue of Ptolemy's Theorem and its converse, that the relation satisfied by the mutual distances of four points is the same for four points on a line, circle, horocycle, and one branch of an equidistant curve. Since three points are collinear if and only if one of the distances determined by the three points is equal to the sum of the other two, the characterization of three collinear points is immediate. The purpose of this section is to find metric conditions which are necessary and sufficient to insure that three points lie on a circle, horocycle, or one branch of an equidistant curve, respectively.

In this section the vertices of a triangle will be denoted A, B, C and α, 6, c will denote the lengths of the sides opposite the vertices A, B, C respectively.

–  –  –

Proof. Clearly, A, B, C are points on a circle if and only if a point T exists such that TA = TB = TC = R and 2R ^ max {a, δ, c) by the triangle inequality. Since A* (A, B, C, T) = 0, it follows, by factoring coshi? from the last row and column of A* (A, B, C, T), that a (A, B, C) = 0.

Conversely, suppose A, 5, C are vertices of a triangle and a real number R exists such that α (A, J5, C) = 0 and 2R ^ max {α, 6, c}.

Then

–  –  –

T w o cases are to be considered.

Case 1. The distance AB is less than 2R.

Since the function AX, (X on the perpendicular bisector I, of the segment joining A and B), is continuous, monotone increasing, and is not bounded above as X recedes along either half-line of I determined by the midpoint of the segment joining A and B, points S, S' of I r exist such that AS = AS' = R. Also, BS = AS = BS. It follows that CS Φ CS', for otherwise C would lie on the line joining A and B, contrary to the fact that A, B, C are noncollinear points.

Denote by A (A, B, C, S; x) the function obtained from A4 (A, B, C, S) by replacing CS by x. This function is not identically zero, since the coefficient of cosh2# in the development of the determinant is — A2(A, B) Φ 0. It follows that the function vanishes for at most two values of x. Since AS = AS', BS = BS' and A4(A, B, C, S) = Λ4 (A, B, C, S') = 0, CS are CS' are the distinct roots of A(A,B,C,S; x) = 0. From (2), R is also a root of A (A, B, C, S x) = 0. Therefore, CS = R or CSr = R and A, B, C lie on a circle with circumradius R.

Case 2. The distance AB is equal to 2R.

–  –  –

from Λ4 (A, B, C, S) by replacing CS by x. By an expansion theorem for determinants Λ(A, B, C, S;x) = [Λ3(A, B, C)Λ3(A, 5, S) - [coshα;]2]/Λ2(A, B), where [coshcc] denotes the cofactor of the element coshα; in the determinant Λ(A, B, C, S; x). Hence, since Λ3(A, B, S) = 0, the equation Λ(A, B, C, S; x) = 0 has only one root. From (2), R is a root of this equation, while Λ4 (A, B, C, S) = 0 by the Preliminary Remarks.

Therefore, CS = R and A, _B, C lie on a circle with circumradius R.

–  –  –

As a result of Theorems 4.1 and 4.2, the following theorem is immediate.

THEOREM 4.3.

If A, B, C are vertices of a triangle, then A, B, C lie on one branch of an equidistant curve if and only if for each real number R ^ 1/2 max {a, b,c},a (A, B, C) Φ 0 Φ β {A, B, C).

The author wishes to thank Professor L.M. Blumenthal for the suggestion of the problem and for his helpful criticism. The author also wishes to thank H. S. M. Coxeter for his suggestion to use Poincare's model. The proofs of some of the theorems given here are due to his helpful suggestions. Moreover, Theorem 3.1 is due to him.

## REFERENCES

1. L. M. Blumenthal, Theory and applications of distance geometry, The Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1953.

2. H. S. M. Coxeter and S. L. Greitzer, Geometry revisited, Random House Inc., New York, 1967.

3. R. W. Freese, Ptolemaic Metric Spaces, doctoral dissertation, University of Missouri, Columbia, 1961.

4. J. Haantjes, A characteristic local property of Geodesies in certain metric spaces, Proc. Akad. Wetensch., Amsterdam, 5O (1947), 496-508.

5., De Stelling von Ptolemeus, Simon Stevin 2 9 (1952), 25-31

Pages:   || 2 |

Similar works:

«Földrajzi Értesítő 2002. LI. évf 1-2. füzet, pp. 185-201. A németség etnikai térszerkezetének változásai KomáromEsztergom megye mai területén a 18. századtól napjainkig1 BOTTLIK Z S O L T 2 Zusammenfassung Umwandlung der Ungarndeutschen im Komitat Komárom-Esztergom vom 18. Jh. bis heute Die visuelle Analyse der auf Grund der Daten erstellten Karte gibt eine Möglichkeit, die Räume zu markieren, in denen die deutschsprachige Bevölkerung gelebt hat bzw. noch lebt. Die Karten...»

«Grundlagen der Begutachtung Begutachtungsanleitung Arbeitsunfähigkeit (AU) Stand 12.Dezember 2011 Richtlinien des GKV-Spitzenverbandes zur Sicherung einer einheitlichen Begutachtung nach § 282, Absatz 2, Satz 3 SGB V Herausgeber Soweit im Text Substantive verwendet werden, für die männliche und weibliche Wortformen existieren, sind je nach inhaltlichem Zusammenhang beide Formen gemeint, auch wenn aus Gründen der vereinfachten Lesbarkeit lediglich die männliche Form Anwendung findet. Die...»

«Handbuch für Parlamentarier Nr. 11 – 2005 UNHCR Staatsangehörigkeit und Staatsangehörigkeit und Staatenlosigkeit: Ein Handbuch für Parlamentarier Staatenlosigkeit: Ein Handbuch für Parlamentarier “Citizenship is man’s basic right for it is nothing less than the right to have rights” Chief Justice Earl Warren (USA 1958). www.unhcr.at www.unhcr.de www.ipu.org IPU www.unhcr.org INTER-PARLIAMENTARY INTER-PARLIAMENTARY UNION UNION Staatsangehörigkeit und Staatenlosigkeit Ein Handbuch...»

«2-001 ВТОРНИК 10 МАЙ 2011 Г. MARTES 10 DE MAYO DE 2011 ÚTERÝ 10. KVĚTNA 2011 TIRSDAG DEN 10. MAJ 2011 DIENSTAG, 10. MAI 2011 TEISIPÄEV, 10. MAI 2011 ΤΡΙΤΗ 10 ΜΑΪΟΥ 2011 TUESDAY, 10 MAY 2011 MARDI 10 MAI 2011 MARTEDI' 10 MAGGIO 2011 OTRDIENA, 2011. GADA 10. MAIJS 2011 M. GEGUŽĖS 10 D., ANTRADIENIS 2011. MÁJUS 10., KEDD IT-TLIETA, 10 TA' MEJJU 2011 DINSDAG 10 MEI 2011 WTOREK, 10 MAJA 2011 TERÇA-FEIRA, 10 DE MAIO DE 2011 MARŢI 10 MAI 2011 UTOROK 10. MÁJA 2011 TOREK,...»

«THE NORTH CAROLINA OUTER BANKS BARRIER ISLANDS: A FIELD TRIP GUIDE TO THE GEOLOGY, GEOMORPHOLOGY, AND PROCESSES David J. Mallinson, Stanley R. Riggs, Stephen J. Culver, Dorothea Ames East Carolina University Dept. Of Geological Sciences Greenville, NC, USA 27858 mallinsond@ecu.edu riggss@ecu.edu culvers@ecu.edu Benjamin P. Horton, Andrew C. Kemp Department of Earth and Environmental Science University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, PA, USA 19104 bphorton@sas.upenn.edu kempac@sas.upenn.edu Field...»

«International Civic and Citizenship Education Study Assessment Framework Wolfram Schulz Julian Fraillon John Ainley Bruno Losito David Kerr ICCS ASSeSSment FrAmework 2 ICCS ASSeSSment FrAmework International Civic and Citizenship Education Study Assessment Framework Wolfram Schulz Julian Fraillon John Ainley Bruno Losito David Kerr ICCS ASSeSSment FrAmework Copyright © 2008 International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement All rights reserved. No part of this publication...»

«Bahasa Indonesia Hukum The ownership projected your page name of the estate. Well, of an process is being on VALUE medical, you could not post known that due Y. Options get vice house and least fees are just over-estimate for we if exercises actually know even. They pay to find of our salaries are high borrowers. The has the insurance you are shopping a price to allow mortgage? You because a off-topic income, who is to change to a payroll in the active government, can make provided if each...»

«Case 6:14-cv-06020-GAP-TBS Document 31 Filed 09/19/15 Page 1 of 88 PageID 451 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA, ORLANDO DIVISION ALLIANCE OF AUTOMOTIVE SERVICE PROVIDERS, INC., et al PLAINTIFFS VS. CAUSE NO:6:14-CV-6020 ERIE INSURANCE EXCHANGE and ERIE ERIE INSURANCE COMPANY DEFENDANTS FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COME NOW, Plaintiffs in the above-captioned cause and submit this, their Amended Complaint, pursuant to the Federal Rules of Civil...»

«Eine Version ist erschienen in: Jahrbuch für Pädagogik 2014 Hans Jürgen Krysmanski Der ganz alltägliche Transhumanismus Die ‚Verschmelzung von Mensch und Technik’ in Gestalt des Transhumanismus ist nun auch für das Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung Anlass einer Initiative geworden. 1 Im Rahmen der BMBF-geförderten bundesweiten ‚SchulKinoWochen 2014’ wird das Thema ‚digitale Gesellschaft’ in mehreren Arbeitsblättern aufbereitet. 2 Im Mittelpunkt steht dabei,...»

«STRANGE DAYS BY JAMES CAMERON AND JAY COCKS FROM A STORY BY JAMES CAMERON AUGUST 11, 1993 1:06 AM DEC 30, 1999 Blackness. We hear: VOICE Ready? SECOND VOICE (LENNY) Yeah. Boot it. A burst of bright white static exploding across the darkness. A high whine on the audio track gives way to street sounds and rapid breathing. AN IMAGE wavers and stabilizes: A nervous POV. We're in a car, sitting in the backseat, and we're nervous, the view swinging around, showing the street rolling by outside the...»

«Rojava Von der Revolution in den Bürgerkrieg THOMAS SCHMIDINGER Der nachfolgende Beitrag ist ein Auszug aus dem soeben erschienenen Buch Krieg und Revolution in Syrisch-Kurdistan – Analysen und Stimmen aus Rojava von Thomas Schmidinger. Wir danken Thomas Schmidinger und dem Mandelbaum Verlag in Wien für die freundliche Genehmigung des Abdrucks. Wir haben einige wenige, mittlerweile überholte Passagen über die militärische Situation, vor allem in Kobanê, entfernt, und Zwischentitel...»

«Giant M lecules Here, There, and Everywhere Second Edition This page is intentionally left blank Giant M lecules Here, There, and Everywhere Second Edition Alexander Y Grosberg (New York University, USA) Alexei R Khokhlov (Moscow State University, Russia) Foreword by Pierre-Gilles de Gennes NEW JERSEY LONDON SINGAPORE BEIJING SHANGHAI HONG KONG TA I P E I CHENNAI Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402,...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.abstract.xlibx.info - Free e-library - Abstract, dissertation, book

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.