WWW.ABSTRACT.XLIBX.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstract, dissertation, book
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:   || 2 |

«Biographical Note: Alexei Borovoy. Brilliant Russian Anarchist theoretician, writer and orator. Professor of Political Economy at Moscow University, ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Anarchism and Law

Alexei Borovoy

Contents

The Problem of Law and the State................................ 3

Imposed and Spontaneous Codes................................. 4

1. Godwin.......................................... 5

2. Proudhon......................................... 5

3. Bakunin.......................................... 5

4. Kropotkin......................................... 6

5. Tucker and the Individualists.............................. 6 Conclusion............................................. 7 Biographical Note: Alexei Borovoy. Brilliant Russian Anarchist theoretician, writer and orator. Professor of Political Economy at Moscow University, prior to and after the Revolution, until ousted by the Bolsheviks. Known and respected throughout Russia, where he had great influence among workers, students and intellectuals. In 1920 the students of Sverdlov petitioned the university administration to permit a series of debates on “Anarchism versus Marxism,” Borovoy representing the Anarchist viewpoint. The local Communist Party, designated the famous Bolsheviks, Bukarin and Lunacharsky, to defend Marxism. The Central Committee of the CP of Russia at the last minute overruled the local CP and forced cancellation of the debates.

Because of his great popularity, the Bolsheviks postponed the silencing of Borovoy until 1929 when he was arrested and deported to Viatka, Siberia, where he died in 1936, the victim of persecution, cold and hunger.

*** In literature concerning anarchism there is a general opinion that anarchism, which negates existing society and existing legal codes, has an equally negative position concerning social codes in general.

This opinion is absolutely false.

The reasons for this error are:

1. confusion over the problem of the relationship between social codes and the State in the writings of anarchists themselves;

2. the variety of definitions of society and social codes in the writings both of anarchists and of their critics;

3. rash statements by certain anarchists who, because of a certain sociological naivete, are sincerely convinced that anarchy is the absence of any sort of regulation;

4. the laziness of those who consider themselves critics of anarchists but do not bother to learn even the essential elements of anarchist thought;

5. finally, conscious distortion, characteristic of the philosophy called “scientific socialism.” The Problem of Law and the State The problem in which we are interested can be presented as follows: Can a society exist in which nothing limits the individual, where all regulation is an affair of the individual and not of the collective will?

Anarchism favors the establishment of a society “of brothers, each of whom contributes his share, living harmoniously, not because of a legal system which severely punishes those who disobey, but because of the force of interpersonal relations, the inevitable force of natural laws.” — Reclus How restrictive are these natural laws? Do they permit of a society in which each individual is free to do as he pleases, or on the other hand, do they require the existence of a State for the preservation of an orderly society?

Impartial sociologists have found that the State (the authoritarian society with an established power) is not the first form of human society. The State appeared as the result of complex phenomena: of a particular material and intellectual culture, of the progressive differentiation of society, of conquest and at the same time of a progressive consciousness of the advantages of solidarity among large groups. The same sociologists have pointed out the parallel growth of the institution of power, which progressively engulfs functions which previously belonged to local and autonomous social organisms.

If some of these functions have been better executed by the new power, others have been executed badly and with a constant disregard for the fundamental rights of the individual.

The process of governmental hypertrophy is well described by Durkheim:

“The governmental power tends to pre-empt all forms of social activity. Among them it is obliged to take upon itself a considerable number of functions for which it is unsuited and which it executes in an insufficient manner. Its passion for bringing everything under its jurisdiction is matched only by its inability to regulate human life. It expends enormous amounts of energy which are totally out of proportion to the obtained results.

“On the other hand, men obey no other collectivity before the State, because the State proclaims itself the only collective organism. They acquire the habit of looking upon society as having a perpetual dependence on the State. And meanwhile, the State is situated very far from them, it remains an

Abstract

entity which cannot exercise an immediate influence, so that in a great part of their lives they move in a void.” It is on this terrain — the tendency of the State to engulf all things, the human person, his social needs, to paralyze his will with threats and sanctions, that the anarchist revolt is born.





Anarchists seek to abolish the State and in general to replace it, not with chaos, but with anew form of organization. They seek to organize society not on the principle of class power, but on the principle of mutual aid.

Imposed and Spontaneous Codes There has not been a single society, even prior to the birth of the State, that has not made certain demands upon its members. While specific regulations may vary from society, some form of regulation is always necessary.

Aside from legal codes, there exist in all societies what can be called codes of convention. Shtamler

points to these:

“In rules of ethical conduct, in interpersonal relationships.., in collective norms such as the chivalric codes of the Middle Ages or the codes of the guilds.” The force of these codes is perhaps greater than the force of laws. The fundamental difference is

that these codes are based on a collective accord:

“Men consent to a collective agreement, perhaps an unconscious one, like the majority of social phenomena, but an agreement nevertheless.” Meanwhile, legal codes are created by a specialized body, detached from society, having as its primary aim the preservation of the established order, which imposes its “sovereignty” without regard to the needs of individual human beings. Genuinely collective codes, based on the free agreement of human beings, can be correctly called anarchist codes. This is recognized by the foremost representatives of anarchist thought, and follows necessarily from the fact that neither social organization nor social progress are consistent with unlimited individual liberty.

After this brief theoretical exposition, we would do well to see what the more important anarchist thinkers have to say about the role of collective codes in future society.

1. Godwin According to Eltzbacher, Godwin opposes all forms of social regulation. However, while he opposes government in all its forms, he speaks of communes as organizations for the collective benefit of all, and points out the necessity of accepting such organizations. Considering the possibility of anti-social acts on the part of particular members of a commune, he speaks of a committee of wise men which would have the power to punish these people or expel them from the group. Furthermore, he envisages regional conferences for the discussion of conflicts betwen communes and for the necessities of defense against the attacks of common enemies. He feels that such institutions would be much more effective than existing ones. Thus he favors the replacement of existing legal codes with the regulation of society by communal organizations.

2. Proudhon There are many seeming contradictions in the work of Proudhon concerning centralization and the State. One can call the institutions advocated by Proudhon “anarchist” and “federalist,” but these institutions carry with them certain governmental characteristics. Even the word “anarchism” is used by Proudhon in two senses: one is the ideal, the vision of a society totally without coercion; the other is simply a form of organization characterized by a preponderance of individual liberty. Proudhon compromises the ideal of anarchism even further. He envisions a society built largely on the principle of centralization, and his federalism follows largely from the overt recognition that anarchy is impossible. In realizing that a realistic solution of social problems must start with a principle of federalism, he makes a realistic compromise between anarchy and democracy.

3. Bakunin No one has written such passionate criticisms of the State as Bakunin. For him the State is an

absolute evil:

“The State is an immense cemetery, the scene of the suicide, death and burial of all manifestations of individual life or collective life — briefly, of life. It is the altar for the sacrifice of liberty and wellbeing, and the more complete this sacrifice is, the more perfect is the State. The State is an abstraction which destroys the life of the people.” But the State, he insists, is a “historically necessary” evil, in the same way that the bestiality of the first humans or the theological imagination of men is necessary. But the State must disappear. It must be replaced by a free society built on the basis of total autonomy; starting with the small commune and building toward a worldwide union joining all men. The relation between different organizations will no longer be violent — it will be imposed not by law but by the free consent of all. The voluntary commune — that is the source of Bakunin’s social norms.

4. Kropotkin Kropotkin, like his predecessors, accepts social norms in relations between men, for example, the obligation to fulfill a freely accepted contract. In “The Conquest of Bread,” for example, he deals extensively with the objections to and false notion of anarchist communism. In his answers he shows himself to be above all a humanist, believing more in human nature than in logic. He correctly insists that the most effective way to deal with antisocial behaviour is to find and remove the reasons for its existence. Meanwhile, such problems as the refusal of some men to work or the refusal to submit to a collective decision can appear even in the most perfect society. In this case, the recalcitrant can always be banished. But in a communist society this can be a terrible punishment, even for the perpetrator of a despicable crime. Unless, of course, the banished criminal simply finds another commune. We must find other solutions.

5. Tucker and the Individualists In his philosophical constructions, Tucker follows the reasoning of Stirner and Proudhon. From Stirner he takes the principle of the absolute sovereignty of the individual; from Proudhon he takes his methods for achieving a free society constructed on the principle of individual agreement.

Like all extreme individualists, Tucker rejects all imposed organization. From there he launches a

violent attack on the State:

“The State is the greatest criminal of our time. It acts not for the defense of its most important unit, that is, the individual, but on the contrary, to limit him, to oppress him, to attack him.” Tucker vehemently criticizes all monopolies: government, the classes it protects, money, laws.

Against monopolies he opposes the principle of unlimited competition:

“General and unlimited competition leads to absolute peace and true cooperation.” From there begins the battle of the anarchist individualists against state socialism — they reproach it as being the victory of the mob over the individual. Under state socialism power arrives at its culminating point, monopolies wield their greatest power. At the same time, the anarchist individualists fail to distinguish between state socialism and anarchist commuism. For them, the latter is a phase in the development of state socialist doctrine.

The characteristic trait of anarchist individualists is their acceptance of private property. The problem they face is the following: can they accept the monopoly of the individual over the product of his labor? If they reply negatively, they give society the right to infringe upon the individual. They have therefore chosen the other response and therefore reintroduce the private ownership of land and the means of production.

From the principle of egoism as the sole motive force of men, Tucker derives the law of equal liberty for all. The limit of the power of each is found precisely in this egoism. The source of social norms based on the will of all is the necessity to accept and honor the liberty of each. Thus the anarchist individualists not only accept certain social norms, but they tend to defend them.

Therefore, in anarchist individualism, as in anarchist communism, we are faced with the tragic impossibility of resolving the incompatibility of the individual and society, the choice between absolute individual liberty or the necessity of a harmonious society.

If anarchism accepts this incompatibility, it turns to the principle which is the proper basis of its theories: the principle of the equality of all members within a free organization. If anarchism does not accept this, it must then accept other social norms.

Conclusion This article follows from the fact that anarchism is not an imaginary dream, but a reality which gives logic and a realistic sense to the revolt of the human spirit against violence. To be anarchist one does not have to speak of fictions such as “absolute, unlimited liberty” and the negation of duty and responsibility. The eternal contradiction, the incompatibility of the individual and society, is insoluable, because it is rooted in the nature of man himself, in his need for independence and his need for society.



Pages:   || 2 |


Similar works:

«291 AMENDED AND RESTATED DYLAWS OF ASPEN HIGHLANDS CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. a nonprofit corporation under the laws of the State of Colorado The following constitute the Amended and Restated Bylaws of ASPEN HIGHLANDS CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., a Colorado nonprofit corporation (the Association) as adopted by the Executive Board effective October 2, 2001. Section 1.1 Purposes. The primary purposes for which the Association is organized is to manage, administer, operate and maintain Aspen...»

«Charities and Insurance May 2012 Contents 1. Introduction 2 2. Why a charity might need insurance the basic considerations 4 3. Risk assessment and decision making 7 4. Insurance for charities that own or occupy land or buildings 9 5. An overview of other insurance cover available 13 Charities and insurance (CC49) 1 1. Introduction 1.1 What is this guidance about? The decision to buy a certain type of insurance (apart from any that the law requires) is one way that charity trustees can carry...»

«Stop Islamization of America (SIOA) A version of this report was originally published in March 2011. Introduction Wake up America! With this cautionary phrase, Stop Islamization of America (SIOA) has sought to rouse public fears about a vast Islamic conspiracy to destroy American values. The organization, created in 2009, warns of the encroachment of Shariah, or Islamic law, in the U.S. and encourages Muslims to renounce and leave the falsity of Islam. The U.S. constitution is under attack from...»

«Virginia Residential Landlord and Tenant Act Effective beginning July 1, 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS SUBJECT PAGE I. Introduction II. Where To Get Information and Advice Legal Aid Societies in Virginia III. Text of the Landlord and Tenant Act Introduction The Virginia Residential Landlord and Tenant Act (hereafter VRLTA) handbook has been prepared to provide information on the rights, remedies, and responsibilities of landlords and renters concerning the rental process. Before signing a lease,...»

«NIU College of law summer Program Agen, France May 26 July 7, 2016 The NIU College of Law Summer Program in Agen, France is approved and accredited by the American Bar Association. This will be the 20th annual summer program offered by Northern Illinois University’s College of Law and the Université Bordeaux, in cooperation with NIU’s Study Abroad Office. PROGRAM DATES: The program will officially begin in Agen, France on Thursday, May 26, 2016 and will end in Agen on Thursday, July 7,...»

«Global Nomad The Backpacker Travel In Manner projects can find reducing if that capture you receive, of developments producing on fifty to 2010-2013 numbers online, in the estate preventing that one to ten issues. Available ones spanish if they to impress your law, of a minute is of common pdf or the website vegetables were fall you, you will find off of these mobi while certain dollars. There are Global Nomad(the) Backpacker Travel in the lot by tools that are your other genre to the of...»

«Hybrid Course Syllabus for MAT 191 (College Algebra) Summer Quarter 2007 Instructor: Paul Godfrey Office hours: 2-3 pm MTWR e-mail: pgodfrey@laniertech.edu Phone: 770 531-6397 Course Description: This course emphasizes techniques of problem solving using algebraic concepts. Topics include: algebraic concepts and operations, linear and quadratic equations and functions, simultaneous equations, inequalities, exponents and powers, graphing techniques, and analytic geometry Competency Areas:...»

«“When we graduate, this is over”: Young Women’s  Experiences with Hooking Up and Relationships  EMILY PAGE  NOVEMBER 30, 2011  SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL SATISFACTION OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR HONORS IN THE  SOCIOLOGY MAJOR  The University of Kansas, a large public university in close proximity to the more metropolitan Kansas City, finds its 30,000 students engaged in a diversity of activities on any given Saturday night. Lawrence, Kansas provides worthy grounds on...»

«Explosive Remnants of War (ERW) Undesired Explosive Events in Ammunition Storage Areas i Explosive Remnants of War (ERW) Undesired Explosive Events in Ammunition Storage Areas ii The Geneva International Centre for Humanitarian Demining (GICHD) supports the efforts of the international community in reducing the impact of mines and unexploded ordnance (UXO). The Centre is active in research, provides operational assistance and supports the implementation of the Anti-Personnel Mine Ban...»

«Directions for Use CAUTION: US Federal law restricts this device to sale by or on the order of a licensed dental professional Doc. No. 87514-0914 Table of Contents 1 Introduction 2 Important Information Indications for Use Contraindications Warnings Precautions Adverse Reactions Applied Symbols 3 Product Overview Overview of the Unit Back Panel 4 Installation and Preparation for Use Location Installation System Icons 5 Set Up Mode Set Up Mode Operations Maintenance & Repair – Within USA...»

«FIXED SITE AMUSEMENT RIDES: DUTY OF CARE – AN ORDINARY NEGLIGENCE STANDARD OR COMMON CARRIER LIABILITY? Ronald J. Cereola James Madison University State courts have adopted differing approaches with respect to the standard of care required to be exercised by fixed site ride operators. The courts are split on the issue of whether or not fixed site amusement rides are common carriers. The determination of common carrier status impacts the degree or standard of care owed patrons. As common...»

«NOTE SOCIAL NETWORKING AND THE FOURTH AMENDMENT: LOCATION TRACKING ON FACEBOOK, TWITTER, AND FOURSQUARE Lisa A. Schmidt* In the 2012 case United States v. Jones, Justice Samuel Alito asked whether the Fourth Amendment might extend any protection to new technology. Although the government may not track an individual through the use of Global Positioning System (GPS) services, the Supreme Court’s past cases suggest that the same protection will not extend to new technologies like social...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.abstract.xlibx.info - Free e-library - Abstract, dissertation, book

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.