FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstract, dissertation, book

Pages:   || 2 |

«Experience and Cultural Models Matter: Placing Firm Limits on Childhood Anthropocentrism Sandra Waxman Douglas Medin Northwestern University, ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --


Human Development 2007;50:23–30

DOI: 10.1159/000097681

Experience and Cultural Models Matter:

Placing Firm Limits on Childhood


Sandra Waxman Douglas Medin

Northwestern University, Evanston, Ill., USA

Key Words

Anthropocentrism Biological concepts Cognitive development Culture

Experience Language development


This paper builds on Hatano and Inagaki’s pioneering work on the role of experience and cultural models in children’s biological reasoning. We use a category-based induction task to consider how experience and cultural models shape rural and urban children’s patterns of biological reasoning. We discuss the implications of these findings for developmental theory and educational practice. Copyright © 2007 S. Karger AG, Basel The Concept ‘Alive’ – A Developmental View Considerable developmental research has been devoted to understanding the acquisition of biological concepts and reasoning. This work has roots in the piagetian tradition, which claimed that children’s reasoning about core biological concepts, such as the concept ‘alive,’ was qualitatively different than that of adults [Piaget, 1954]. In particular, young children’s responses in Piagetian interviews led to a widely held view that they were animistic in their thinking, attributing living kind status to a broad range of nonliving entities (e.g., clouds, bicycles). In other tasks, however, young children respond differently, tending to attribute living kind status to an overly restricted set of entities (to animals, but not plants) [Hatano, et al., 1993;

Keil, 1983; Opfer & Siegler, 2004; Stavy & Wax, 1989]. Another key finding in this arena concerns young children’s apparent anthropocentrism, in which they tend to rely heavily on humans as a privileged inductive base whenever they are asked to attribute biological properties (e.g., being alive, having a heart) to other animals.

Clearly, questions concerning the nature of the biological concepts held by children and their relation to those held by adults are very much alive.

© 2007 S. Karger AG, Basel Sandra Waxman, Department of Psychology Northwestern University, Swift Hall 2029 Sheridan Road, Evanston, IL 60208 (USA) Fax +41 61 306 12 34 E-Mail karger@karger.ch Accessible online at: Tel. +1 847 467 2293, Fax +1 847 491 7859 www.karger.com/hde E-Mail s-waxman@northwestern.edu www.karger.com The Pioneering Contributions of Giyoo Hatano Giyoo Hatano’s fresh insights into this area of inquiry cannot be overestimated.

In his pioneering work with his longtime collaborator Kayoko Inagaki, he has made lasting theoretical and educational contributions regarding the biological concepts held by children. Our goal in this paper is to honor their contributions, pointing out the ways in which their insights into the role of experience and cultural models have shaped our cross-cultural developmental research program on biological reasoning.

Culture, Experience and Childhood Anthropocentrism

Captivated by the issue of biological concepts and reasoning, domain specificity, and developmental change, Hatano and Inagaki [Inagaki & Hatano, 1993, 1996, 2002; Hatano & Inagaki, 1994, 1999, 2000] launched a multifaceted developmental research program. In one line of work, they considered how the cultural models espoused within a community shape children’s biological reasoning. These studies revealed that 5- to 8-year-old Japanese children understand many bodily processes in terms of vitalism – a causal model that is pervasive in Japan and that relies on the distinctly biological concept of energy.1 In another facet of their ingenious program, Inagaki and Hatano [Inagaki, 1990;

Hatano & Inagaki, 1994; Inagaki & Hatano, 2002] focused on children’s direct experience and identified a potential source for the anthropocentric pattern we described earlier. Of course, children’s experiences with the biological world are varied, including not only the cultural models and beliefs espoused within the community, but also their habitual surroundings (e.g., rural vs. urban), their informal learning opportunities (e.g., direct hands-on experience, including farming, fishing, summer camp activities), and perhaps more remotely, their experiences in more formal learning environments and access to videos, books, and visits to the zoo [Inagaki, 1990;

Rosengren, Gelman, Kalish, & McCormick, 1991].

Hatano and Inagaki examined the role of experience by identifying urban Japanese children who had cared for and raised goldfish in their homes, and those who had not. When they then assessed these children’s attributions of biological properties, they found that children without goldfish-raising experience showed an anthropocentric pattern, but that those who had raised goldfish did not. This suggests that anthropocentrism may be mediated by children’s experience, a point to which we will return below.

Still, the anthropocentric pattern produced by urban Japanese children who did not raise goldfish converged well with Carey’s [1985] results with urban Boston children’s performance in a category-based induction task. In this task, an interviewer introduced children to a picture of a biological entity (either a human, dog, or bee) and taught them about an unfamiliar biological property (e.g., has an omentum) of that entity. Next, children were asked whether that novel property could also be generalized to other entities [including other humans, nonhuman animals, inanimate natural kinds (e.g., sun), and artifacts (e.g., garlic presses)]. Carey [1985] reported Vitalism is not restricted to Japanese children: Australian children also preferred vitalistic explanations for bodily phenomena [Morris, Taplin, & Gelman, 2000].

Human Development Waxman/Medin 2007;50:23–30 that 4- and 6-year-olds, unlike older children and adults, hold an anthropocentric conception of the biological world, treating human as a privileged inferential base.

She took this finding as evidence that young children’s knowledge pertaining to the biological world is organized around a model in which humans stand as the prototypical exemplar, and that development in this domain is characterized by pervasive conceptual change which is necessary to catapult children from this anthropocentric model to the more adult (Western science-oriented) model in which humans stand as one animal among many (Medin and Waxman [in press] provide an extended discussion of alternative interpretations of these asymmetries in induction).

Limits on Childhood Anthropocentrism

Importantly, however, the evidence from Hatano and Inagaki suggested that there may be limits on this anthropocentrism: this pattern may not be universal, but may instead be mediated by experience. This also challenged the view that development within the domain of biological knowledge necessarily entails radical conceptual change [Carey, 1985]. In fact, it suggested an alternative: urban children’s propensity to view humans as a privileged inductive base may be driven by their relatively impoverished knowledge about animal kinds other than humans. If this interpretation is correct, then children with more knowledge and experience with the biological world should be less likely to reason anthropocentrically. This, of course, is exactly the pattern observed in urban Japanese goldfish-raising children.

In our research, we have been inspired by Hatano and Inagaki to pursue this possibility experimentally. We are involved in a cross-cultural developmental series of studies on biological knowledge and reasoning spanning several different communities [Anggoro, Waxman, & Medin, 2005; Ross, Medin, Coley, & Atran, 2003, Medin & Atran, 2004; Waxman, Medin & Ross, in press]. In this paper, we focus on urban versus rural children being raised in the USA. The logic underlying this urban-rural comparison is straightforward: with regard to experience, rural children are the counterpart of Inagaki and Hatano’s goldfish raisers, except that they likely have even more extensive experience with a wider variety of biological kinds. Thus far, our results with rural children offer no evidence for an anthropocentric pattern, providing support for the view that children’s experience with a biological kind affects the strength of that kind as an inductive base [Atran et al., 2001; Ross, et al., 2003; Medin & Waxman, in press]. However, the performance of our urban Chicago preschool-aged children throws a fly in the ointment: they too have failed to show the anthropocentric pattern [Anggoro, et al, 2005].

Why might this be the case? Perhaps this discrepancy in the performance of urban children in our work and in Carey’s and Hatano and Inagaki’s studies reflects, at least in part, a methodological difference in experimental design. In these latter versions, information about a biological kind is gathered at one point in time, and children participate in the category-based induction task several days later. Carey’s version involved explicit teaching. Children were introduced to a base object (either a human, dog, or bee) and taught extensively about a novel property of that object (e.g. ‘has an omentum’). In Inagaki and Hatano’s designs, there was no explicit teaching: they simply measured the cognitive consequences of intensive experience raising goldfish. We refer to procedures like these, in which training occurs prior to the Experience and Cultural Models Human Development 25 2007;50:23–30 category-based induction test, as ‘spontaneous generalization’ tasks. In contrast, in our lab we have relied upon what we might call ‘prompted generalization’: we teach children that some biological entity (e.g., a human or a dog) has some biological property (e.g., an omentum) and then immediately observe children’s inductive inferences from this base to a variety of other kinds.

Investigating Anthropocentrism in US Children from Rural and Urban Communities To examine the consequences of this methodological difference, we designed a close conceptual replication of Carey’s procedure. On day 1, children were introduced to a novel property and were taught that this was a property true of either humans, dogs, or bees. On day 2, children were given an opportunity to project that property to a range of kinds in a spontaneous generalization task. To examine the role of experience, we worked with urban and rural children. If the discrepant results for young urban children reflect primarily methodological differences, then in the current task, urban children should reveal an anthropocentric pattern, treating humans as a stronger inductive base than either of the nonhuman animals (dog, bee). Moreover, if experience with biological kinds shapes the trajectory of children’s biological reasoning, then rural children should not treat humans as a privileged inductive base.

We tested 203 4- to 7-year-old children from public schools in Shawano, Wisc.

(rural) and Chicago, Ill. (urban). Shawano County is replete with farmland, small forest plots, and lakes and rivers. Hunting, fishing, and water recreation are popular activities for adults and children. For children in Chicago, recruited from a racially and ethnically diverse public magnet school, direct contact with animals is generally more limited to visits to the zoo, caring for pets, and noticing the native animals (squirrels, pigeons) that live in urban areas. Table 1 shows the number of children in each community and age group.

Children were interviewed individually in a quiet place in their school on two different days. On the first day, they were introduced to an object (either a human, a dog or a squirrel) and taught that a novel property (e.g., ‘has an omentum’) applied to that kind of object. Children then answered a few questions about their pets and outdoor activities. A day or two later, children completed the category-based induction task, involving color photographs of 16 target items, including a person, dog, bear, aardvark, bee, fly, eagle, toucan, trout, angel fish, maple tree, dandelion, sun, rock, computer, and pencil. For each photograph, children were asked, ‘Do Xs have an omentum?’2 We computed each child’s tendency to generalize the novel property from their designated base to the targets.

The results, depicted in figure 1, indicated that the anthropocentric pattern was apparent only in the youngest urban children, and only weakly so at that. In every other group, nonhuman animal bases (both dogs and bees) were on at least equal footing with humans in their inductive strength. Thus, in this ‘spontaneous’ version of the category-based induction task, we more or less replicated Carey’s and Inagaki and Hatano’s anthropocentric pattern – but only with our youngest urban children.

We described the base and target items with generic nouns to clarify the category-based nature of the task.

–  –  –

0.75 0.75 Fig. 1. Mean proportion of inferences from each inductive base to each target category, expressed as a function of age and community.

Table 1. The number of children in each community and age group who were trained on each base

–  –  –

We did not observe an anthropocentric pattern in any other population – including the young rural children.

This pattern of results suggests that although procedural differences may be instrumental in the expression of an anthropocentric pattern in young urban children, a thorough developmental account will need to go beyond task and age considerations alone. Perhaps most importantly, the current results underscore the importance of considering the role of experience in the development of core biological concepts and reasoning. This focus on experience brings us full circle back to the insights provided by Hatano [Hatano & Inagaki, 1994; Inagaki & Hatano, 2002].

–  –  –

Pages:   || 2 |

Similar works:

«Amino Acids Building Blocks of Proteins Introduction Proteins are more than an important part of your diet. Proteins are complex molecular machines that are involved in nearly all of your cellular functions. Each protein has a specific shape (structure) that enables it to carry out its specific job (function). A core idea in the life sciences is that there is a fundamental relationship between a biological structure and the function it must perform. At the macro level, Darwin recognized that...»

«ARTICULATA 2002 17(2): 19-31 BIOLOGIE A Field Study of the Escape Behaviour of Tetrix subulata (LINNAEUS, 1758) and Tetrix tenuicornis (SAHLBERG, 1893) (Orthoptera: Tetrigidae) Axel Hochkirch, Marco Zimmermann, Christian Keithahn, Stefan Länder, Andrea Peiter, Michael Folger-Rüter, Carola Harmuth, Stefan Vogt, Marion Zimmermann, Frauke Hellwig, Anke Gulau & Helge Mühl Zusammenfassung Das Fluchtverhalten von Heuschrecken ist noch weitgehend unerforscht, obgleich es eine der auffälligsten...»

«Available online at www.scholarsresearchlibrary.com Scholars Research Library Annals of Biological Research, 2014, 5 (10):6-13 (http://scholarsresearchlibrary.com/archive.html) ISSN 0976-1233 CODEN (USA): ABRNBW Development of improved doubled-haploids through anther culture of indica rice (Oryza sativa L.) A. K. M. Mohiuddin1*, Nilufer Hye Karim2 and Shahanaz Sultana2 Department of Biotechnology and Genetic Engineering, Mawlana Bhashani Science and Technology University, Tangail, Bangladesh...»

«Polymer Supported Organocatalysts for Regioand Stereoselective Synthesis DISSERTATION zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades des Doktors der Naturwissenschaften (Dr. rer. nat) eingereicht im Fachbereich Biologie, Chemie und Pharmazie der Freien Universität Berlin vorgelegt von Florian Mummy aus Magdeburg Juli 2012 Diese Arbeit wurde unter der Anleitung von Prof. Dr. Rainer Haag im Zeitraum von Juni 2007 bis Juni 2012 am Institut für Chemie und Biochemie der Freien Universität Berlin...»

«2013 IO C B IP S P ce Confere n 9th Conference on Integrated Protection of Stored Products IPSP 2013 Programme & Abstracts Agora University Bordeaux 1 TALENCE, FRANCE 1 4 July, 2013 https://colloque.inra.fr/iobc-ipsp-2013conference Integrated Protection of Stored Products – 2013 Conference – Bordeaux, France – 01–04 July 2013 Table of content Heading Page Foreword 3 Avant-propos 4 IPSP 2013 Conference Committees 5 Conference program general schedule 6 Timetable and list of oral...»

«Metalltranslocon Komplexe in Chloroplasten Dissertation zur Erlangung des Doktorgrades der Fakultät für Biologie der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München vorgelegt von Roland Stübe am 13.12.2012 Dissertation eingereicht am: 13.12.2012 Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 12.02.2013 Erstgutachterin: PD Dr. Katrin Philippar Zweitgutachter: Prof. Dr. Jörg Nickelsen INHALTSVERZEICHNIS ABKÜRZUNGEN I. ZUSAMMENFASSUNG II. EINLEITUNG: Übergangsmetalle in Pflanzen II.1. Aufnahme der Übergangsmetalle...»

«Dedication About the authors Preface Tools and Techniques Clinical Applications Molecular Evolution Supplements Supporting Biochemistry, Fifth Edition Acknowledgments I. The Molecular Design of Life 1. Prelude: Biochemistry and the Genomic Revolution 1.1. DNA Illustrates the Relation between Form and Function 1.2. Biochemical Unity Underlies Biological Diversity 1.3. Chemical Bonds in Biochemistry 1.4. Biochemistry and Human Biology Appendix: Depicting Molecular Structures 2. Biochemical...»

«Effect of Oxygen Partial Pressure and COD Loading on Biofilm Performance in a Membrane Aerated Bioreactor Ivan Xuetang Zhu A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Chemical Engineering and Applied Chemistry University of Toronto  Copyright by Ivan Xuetang Zhu 2008 Effect of Oxygen Partial Pressure and COD Loading on Biofilm Performance in a Membrane Aerated Bioreactor Doctor of Philosophy, 2008 Ivan Xuetang Zhu Department of...»

«Arch. Tierz., Dummerstorf 50 (2007) 3, 294-308 Forschungsinstitut für die Biologie landwirtschaftlicher Nutztiere (FBN), Dummerstorf, Germany CHRISTINE BAES and NORBERT REINSCH Computing the condensed conditional gametic QTL relationship matrix and its inverse Abstract The inverse of the conditional gametic relationship matrix ( G -1 ) for a marked quantitative trait locus (MQTL) is required for estimation of gametic effects in best linear unbiased prediction (BLUP) of breeding values if...»

«EFFECT OF THERMAL PROCESSING ON THE PHENOLIC ANTIOXIDANTS OF COLORED POTATOES By BALUNKESWAR NAYAK A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY Department of Biological Systems Engineering MAY 2011 To the Faculty of Washington State University: The members of the Committee appointed to examine the dissertation of BALUNKESWAR NAYAK find it satisfactory and recommend that it be accepted. _ Juming Tang,...»

«Joint Conference: TRDRP, CDPH, CDE October 27-29, 2015, Sacramento, CA POSTER SESSION: How Tobacco Causes Disease (DAY-1: Tuesday, October 27, 5:35-6:30PM) Abstract# 1-19 Compendium of Abstracts 2 Joint Conference: TRDRP, CDPH, CDE October 27-29, 2015, Sacramento, CA Thirdhand Smoke Causes DNA Damage and Cell Transformation in vitro 1Bo Hang1*, Altaf H. Sarker1, Yurong Huang1, Jian-Hua Mao1, Kelly S Trego1, Ahmed Chenna3, Christopher Havel4, Anthony Iavarone5, Saikat Saha6, Peyton Jacob, III4,...»

«Evolution modularer Multienzymsysteme des bakteriellen Sekundärstoffwechsels Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades doctor rerum naturalium (Dr. rer. nat.) im Fach Biologie eingereicht an der Mathematisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät I der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin von Holger Michael Jenke-Kodama, geb. Jenke geboren am 25.09.1969 in Reutlingen Präsident der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin Prof. Dr. Christoph Markschies Dekan der Mathematisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.abstract.xlibx.info - Free e-library - Abstract, dissertation, book

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.